Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access – Which VPN is better?
Proton VPN or Private Internet Access – which VPN suits you better? We tested both providers across speed, security, and price.
Our winner
Proton VPN
In this head-to-head comparison Proton VPN delivers the better overall performance.
See Proton VPN deal →Comparison table
Speed – Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access
The speed comparison shows a clear gap: Proton VPN delivers 80 Mbit/s, Private Internet Access reaches 80 Mbit/s. Both values are fine for everyday use.
Security – Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access
The security architecture is solid on both sides: AES-256, kill switch and no-logs are standard. Proton VPN adds No-logs policy (Schweiz) and AES-256 Encryption, Private Internet Access adds No-logs policy (checked) and AES-256 Encryption.
- No-logs policy (Schweiz)
- AES-256 Encryption
- Secure Core Server
- Kill Switch
- No-logs policy (checked)
- AES-256 Encryption
- Kill Switch
- Open source apps
Streaming – which VPN works better?
Streaming fans should pay attention: Proton VPN handles 3 platforms, Private Internet Access handles 4. Proton VPN is the more reliable choice for Netflix and similar services.
Proton VPN
Private Internet Access
Pricing
Private Internet Access
from 2,03 €/month
3-year subscription - 30-day money-back guarantee
See Private Internet Access dealWhich VPN is better for…
Streaming
Proton VPN
Proton VPN unblocks streaming services slightly more reliably.
Security
Proton VPN
More security functions and features.
Value for money
Private Internet Access
Lower price with comparable performance.
Our verdict – Proton VPN or Private Internet Access?
Proton VPN secures the win in our comparison. That said: Private Internet Access is a solid VPN service and pays off depending on your requirements and budget.
FAQ – Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access
Is Proton VPN or Private Internet Access faster? +
Proton VPN is a bit faster on average (80 Mbit/s vs 80 Mbit/s). Both deliver good speeds for streaming and downloads.
Which VPN is cheaper – Proton VPN or Private Internet Access? +
Private Internet Access is cheaper (from 2,03 €/month). Proton VPN starts at 4,99 €/month.
Which VPN is more secure? +
Both offer AES-256 encryption and no-logs policies. Proton VPN packs a few more security features.
Which VPN is better for streaming? +
Proton VPN unblocks streaming services slightly more reliably in our test. Both VPNs work with Netflix and other platforms.
Should you still go with Private Internet Access? +
Yes, in some scenarios. Private Internet Access convinces with its own strengths and can be the more fitting choice depending on your needs.
