Surfshark vs Private Internet Access – Which VPN is better?
Surfshark vs Private Internet Access – a comparison worth reading. We put both VPN services through their paces: speed, security, streaming and cost.
Our winner
Surfshark
In this head-to-head comparison Surfshark delivers the better overall performance.
See Surfshark deal →Comparison table
Speed – Surfshark vs Private Internet Access
Surfshark reaches higher download speeds on average (85 Mbit/s vs 80 Mbit/s). Private Internet Access still delivers solid performance for streaming and everyday browsing.
Security – Surfshark vs Private Internet Access
Both providers rely on AES-256 encryption and a no-logs policy. Surfshark offers No-logs policy, AES-256 Encryption, Kill Switch, CleanWeb Ad blocker. Private Internet Access offers No-logs policy (checked), AES-256 Encryption, Kill Switch, Open source apps.
- No-logs policy
- AES-256 Encryption
- Kill Switch
- CleanWeb Ad blocker
- No-logs policy (checked)
- AES-256 Encryption
- Kill Switch
- Open source apps
Streaming – which VPN works better?
In the streaming comparison Surfshark scores with broader platform coverage. Both VPNs unblock the most common services – Surfshark is just a bit more consistent.
Surfshark
Private Internet Access
Pricing
Surfshark
from 2,49 €/month
2-year subscription - 30-day money-back guarantee - Unlimited devices
See Surfshark dealPrivate Internet Access
from 2,03 €/month
3-year subscription - 30-day money-back guarantee
See Private Internet Access dealWhich VPN is better for…
Streaming
Surfshark
Surfshark unblocks streaming services slightly more reliably.
Security
Surfshark
More security functions and features.
Value for money
Surfshark
Lower price with comparable performance.
Our verdict – Surfshark or Private Internet Access?
Surfshark delivers the better overall performance in this comparison. Private Internet Access is still a solid alternative and can be the better pick for specific use cases.
FAQ – Surfshark vs Private Internet Access
Is Surfshark or Private Internet Access faster? +
Surfshark is a bit faster on average (85 Mbit/s vs 80 Mbit/s). Both deliver good speeds for streaming and downloads.
Which VPN is cheaper – Surfshark or Private Internet Access? +
Surfshark is cheaper (from 2,49 €/month). Private Internet Access starts at 2,03 €/month.
Which VPN is more secure? +
Both offer AES-256 encryption and no-logs policies. Surfshark packs a few more security features.
Which VPN is better for streaming? +
Surfshark unblocks streaming services slightly more reliably in our test. Both VPNs work with Netflix and other platforms.
When is Private Internet Access the better choice? +
Private Internet Access is the better choice when specific features or a lower entry price matter more to you than maximum overall performance.
